Spring is finally upon us. Long walks, pool parties, hikes and beach days are all part of the schedule. And, if you own a canine, it’s the perfect time to embark on those spring adventures and play dates that you’ve been longing to finally get to. But as you would have it, as temperatures rise, so too does the chance of your dog being infected by fleas and ticks.
And, let’s face it: dog fleas and ticks are more of a looming menace. You don’t see them or notice that they are there but when you do you can’t help but be frightened. Mostly, because other than being a total nuisance, they can also be quite the dangerous pair. And the worst part: it doesn’t matter how clean you try to keep your pooch, as long as the conditions are favorable, they’ll hop right on and do what they do best: be a total nuisance. And then it won’t be long before they start moving out of the shadows and distant corners to every single part of your house.Scary, right?
Luckily, there are plenty of flea and tick treatments available on the market. Some are obviously better than others but work all the same. However, if you’re looking for a lasting solution to those pesky pests, your best bet is the Advantage flea treatment and the Advantix flea treatment. The featured piece takes a closer look at the glaring differences between the two products and also explains in depth what the two are.
Let’s get to it, shall we?
What Is Advantage?
Advantage is a comprehensive monthly flea medication that treats adult fleas and flea larvae. It comes in a tube of liquid form that lasts up to a period of 1 month and is available for purchase in multiples of 4 and 12 packs as well as single doses.
What Is Advantix?
Also known as K9 Advantix, this topical flea treatment not only treats adult fleas but also flea larvae, flea allergy dermatitis, and ticks. In addition, it can also be used to repel mosquitoes, sand flies, and biting flies. It comes in a small tube of liquid form and can be used for up to 1 month and is water-resistant for a period of up to 1 month. It is available in both single and multiples doses of 3, 6, and 12 packs
Advantage vs. Advantix: Price
While Advantage and Advantix are seemingly similar in so many ways, the two treatments have slightly different prices. For instance, 6 Advantage treatments cost about $56.99, whereas 6 Advantix treatments cost well around $65.99. Now, while it’s true that money is no object when it comes to health, we definitely can’t ignore the fact that the price plays a vital role when we are making a purchase decision. So, if you’re on a budget, the Advantage flea treatment works just as well as the Advantix flea treatment when it boils down to performance. And it will cost you much less too. However, prices vary almost every day and so what’s cheap today might be seriously expensive tomorrow.
Active Ingredients and How They Work
Both of these treatments are highly effective in treating and preventing fleas in dogs.But when comparing the ingredients, there are some notable differences. Advantix contains Permethrin, imidacloprid, and Pyriproxyfen and a blend of other unspecified ingredients. On the other hand, the active ingredients in Advantage are Imidacloprid and Pyriproxyfen.
Advantage vs. Advantix: Adverse Reactions
With both Advantage and Advantix, the chances of side effects and adverse reactions are slim. The most common reaction, however, could be a little irritation at the treatment site that clears up almost as quickly as it begun leaving absolutely no marks. There are also some occasions where a small percentage of the dogs experience a burning, itching, tingling sensation coupled with redness or numbness of the skin which is perfectly normal and clears up within two hours. However, if you have multiple pets around your house, then it could be a problem. Advantix contains Permethrin which is great for dogs but can be lethal to cats.
Advantage vs. Advantix: Reviews
According to ratings on Amazon, Advantage scores better than Advantix. Advantage has a rating of 4.3, whereas Advantix follows closely with a rating of 3.7. However, while Advantage seems to be better than Advantix if reviews are anything to go by, there were still a couple of complaints with some people expressing their dissatisfaction with the new Advantage 11. On the other hand, Advantix contains Permethr in which is often hailed for its superb ability to eradicate fleas completely.
Advantage vs. Advantix: Effectiveness
While effectiveness is dependent on how well you use the treatment, some resources suggest a few trends when comparing the two. For instance, Advantix has an added versatility that facilitates both the killing and repelling of fleas, ticks, and other biting flies whereas Advantage only does the killing.
Another slight but significant difference in regard to effectiveness is the age and weight that each product serves. For instance, Advantix can be used on puppies as long as they weigh 4 pounds and above and are over 7 weeks old. Advantage, on the other hand, cannot be used on puppies and dogs under 7 weeks old and 55 pounds in weight.
In terms of how long it takes the product to work on your pet, some vets believe that Advantage works slightly faster than Advantix. Bayer’s claims that Advantage works within 4–12 hours of application whereas Advantix works within 12 hours of application.
How to Apply
Both Advantage and Advantix are applied topically on to the pooch’s skin.
|Advantage||§ It takes 4–12 hours to work.
§ It costs $56.99.
§ It has a three-way protection that kills the eggs, larvae, and adults.
§ It breaks the flea’s life cycle to prevent re-infestation.
§ It has a waterproof formula that continues working even after you’ve bathed your pooch.
|§ It doesn’t kill ticks.|
|Advantix||§ It costs $65.99.
§ It has added versatility that makes it suitable for repelling and treating fleas, ticks, and mosquitoes on contact.
§ It has a waterproof formula that ensures that it is still effective even after bathing.
§ It starts working within 12 hours.
|§ It is more costly than other brands.
§ It contains multiple ingredients which can be harmful to dogs with sensitive skin and lethal to cats.
The Bottom Line
Based on the factors we have analyzed, Advantage is the best flea treatment on the market. It is reasonably priced, effective,and is perfect for both dogs and cats. However, be sure to discuss treatments with the vet before you apply any of these products.